: Which Pads?



g10far
27-12-2011, 18:25:36
I'll soon need to change my pads and have been told that Pagids are good. I am currently running DS2500's.

Does anyone use Pagids at all, would appreciate any info.

Cheers

a16pse
27-12-2011, 18:29:22
I use carbotec xp8s , their expensive but their awsome on road and track and never fade

Bahnstormer
27-12-2011, 19:04:16
road or track?

Brano
27-12-2011, 20:11:01
CL5+ are good (track only), just the discs dont like them :)

Bahnstormer
27-12-2011, 20:15:05
They fall off the backing plates. Avoid.

Bahnstormer
27-12-2011, 20:15:30
PF for me. For track only though

a16pse
27-12-2011, 20:57:10
Well I use XP8s their meant for track which they are fantastic for having said that their also the best pad I've used in my R26 for the road as well

Streetfighter
27-12-2011, 21:07:24
I've used RS29s, they're a great endurance pad and work perfectly from cold - 2 negative points I found:
1 - they are rock hard, virtually no modulation (you might think pad is incompressible but it's not).
2 - you may suffer pad pick up depending which discs you're using

gustavb
27-12-2011, 21:15:41
They fall off the backing plates. Avoid.

bahn, you mean the RC5+ or ??

i wouldn't use the Ferodo's anymore - at least on track. they've melted on my rotors after half a day @track

Brano
27-12-2011, 21:22:08
bahn, you mean the RC5+ or ??

i wouldn't use the Ferodo's anymore - at least on track. they've melted on my rotors after half a day @track

dont you told me Gusto you melted them after 4days on track ?

gustavb
27-12-2011, 21:55:06
they were about 4 days old in total. first three days haven't been that busy, but the last day - i was using them really hard under commandment of driving instructor and in the afternoon i've noticed those strange sounds while braking..

Brano
27-12-2011, 22:21:32
will be nice to see how long the OEM pads will survive with the same style :)

Bahnstormer
28-12-2011, 00:02:46
bahn, you mean the RC5+ or ??

i wouldn't use the Ferodo's anymore - at least on track. they've melted on my rotors after half a day @track

I'm referring to RC5+

gustavb
28-12-2011, 08:16:50
I'm referring to RC5+

thats not nice to hear Kev as i have them on my wheels as well.. so far didn't have any problem though. just had to change to Castrol's SRF as they were boiling Motul's 660 constantly

gustavb
28-12-2011, 08:17:24
will be nice to see how long the OEM pads will survive with the same style :)

1-2days it i recall correctly

jaybyme
28-12-2011, 08:36:24
I luv the CL5+ and grooved disc setup on mine.
After driving my TT RS for a while and then jumping in the Meg,it's the first thing you notice.The stopping power of the Meg is much better.

Bahnstormer
28-12-2011, 08:59:27
thats not nice to hear Kev as i have them on my wheels as well.. so far didn't have any problem though. just had to change to Castrol's SRF as they were boiling Motul's 660 constantly

I was not the first to report this. In fact I only concurred at the beginning of this month when I removed them early to replace with PF.

gustavb
28-12-2011, 09:24:55
I was not the first to report this. In fact I only concurred at the beginning of this month when I removed them early to replace with PF.

and what pads from PF are you using? and what brake discs you have at the moment?
thanks for info Kevin, hope we'll meet @Geneva this year as usual ..

Bahnstormer
28-12-2011, 09:35:38
Yeah Ill be there. Doing some work with a Film crew!
Im running PF07's on the front and 01's rear. PF discs.No washers so fully floating.

a16pse
28-12-2011, 09:37:43
Forget the rest get yourself a set of carbotec XP8s I've been through most of the decent makes and I'll stick with these now I've not had one bit of fade with them after 5 track days , like I say they get better and better as the day goes on

Bahnstormer
28-12-2011, 10:04:30
Ive never seen carbotech on a race car. PF on the other hand............

Streetfighter
28-12-2011, 10:20:48
They fall off the backing plates. Avoid.

Fair enough this is a critical component but a rather sweeping statement. According to other users there was one bad batch which was recognised, it's not a general failing of the product is it?

gustavb
28-12-2011, 10:30:33
film crew Kevin? what news? tell me more

Bahnstormer
28-12-2011, 10:50:26
Fair enough this is a critical component but a rather sweeping statement. According to other users there was one bad batch which was recognised, it's not a general failing of the product is it?

HI wouldn't call it a sweeping statement. How many people do we know that fitted them? And how many people had the problem? And considering we didn't all buy them at the same time, how big is this "batch".

Bahnstormer
28-12-2011, 10:51:07
film crew Kevin? what news? tell me more

It's just work. Nothing to write home about.

gustavb
28-12-2011, 11:10:05
Yeah Ill be there. Doing some work with a Film crew!
Im running PF07's on the front and 01's rear. PF discs.No washers so fully floating.

wher do you get these from? i'm struggling to find them online. thanks

Streetfighter
28-12-2011, 11:11:35
HI wouldn't call it a sweeping statement. How many people do we know that fitted them? And how many people had the problem? And considering we didn't all buy them at the same time, how big is this "batch".

Hello, honestly? I personally know of 3, all of which were replaced FOC as you would expect. No idea on batch size, I would expect the producer has systems in place to quantify it with start and finish points.
As for the not purchasing at the same time that might be explained by the supply chain. Were they all purchased from the same source? There's any number of explanations.
I'm not looking for an off topic crusade but the pads were by all accounts a good product until this one mistake, would be a pity for someone not to try a generally good product based on what should be a contained issue :)

Streetfighter
28-12-2011, 11:12:40
wher do you get these from? i'm struggling to find them online. thanks

http://www.track-group.com/Renaultsport-Megane-Performance-Friction-Race-Pad-Set---Front-07-Compound-p154858.html

http://www.track-group.com/track-and-race-day-products-renaultsport-performance-b153176.html

Bahnstormer
28-12-2011, 11:13:54
I just wouldn't want someone to send money on something that 3/3 turned out to be substandard.

Don't avoid then. Ignore me. It's just my experience. Draw your own conclusions.

Streetfighter
28-12-2011, 11:21:48
I just wouldn't want someone to send money on something that 3/3 turned out to be substandard.

Don't avoid then. Ignore me. It's just my experience. Draw your own conclusions.

I agree and informing people of our collective experience is great, that's what makes forums, after that only they should decide.
Most will not take the risk anyway so i'm sure no one needs to ignore you!

gustavb
28-12-2011, 11:23:46
http://www.track-group.com/Renaultsport-Megane-Performance-Friction-Race-Pad-Set---Front-07-Compound-p154858.html

http://www.track-group.com/track-and-race-day-products-renaultsport-performance-b153176.html

many thanks

Bahnstormer
28-12-2011, 11:25:16
Speak to Stephen Docherty there. Good guy. I owe him lunch.

+MJ+
28-12-2011, 11:48:06
I went for the RC5+ after hearing all the horror stories about the pads removing them selves from the backing, pad surface braking up etc etc. They got put in end of summer so I havn't thrashed them round a track yet but for fast road I've no complaints. First time I slammed on the breaks the abs kicked in and I nearly shot out my seat.

Bahnstormer
28-12-2011, 12:20:17
Pads are good. I was just surprised to find them in 3 pieces when only half worn.

g10far
28-12-2011, 14:47:21
road or track?

Well Ideally it would be more for track as I use the car less during the week. I quite like the idea of changing the discs to something bigger, but I have heard mixed reviews and think I'll just go for a pad change at the moment as the discs are still ok.

Have you ever used Pagids Bahnstormer?

jmeBDC
28-12-2011, 16:12:17
http://www.track-group.com/Renaultsport-Megane-Performance-Friction-Race-Pad-Set---Front-07-Compound-p154858.html

http://www.track-group.com/track-and-race-day-products-renaultsport-performance-b153176.html


Thanks ;)

Bahnstormer
28-12-2011, 17:10:51
Well Ideally it would be more for track as I use the car less during the week. I quite like the idea of changing the discs to something bigger, but I have heard mixed reviews and think I'll just go for a pad change at the moment as the discs are still ok.

Have you ever used Pagids Bahnstormer?
No. Though they're usually quite good. I found my setup now ;)

fredrickr26
05-01-2012, 22:20:57
Hello, honestly? I personally know of 3, all of which were replaced FOC as you would expect. No idea on batch size, I would expect the producer has systems in place to quantify it with start and finish points.
As for the not purchasing at the same time that might be explained by the supply chain. Were they all purchased from the same source? There's any number of explanations.
I'm not looking for an off topic crusade but the pads were by all accounts a good product until this one mistake, would be a pity for someone not to try a generally good product based on what should be a contained issue :)



http://www.exiges.com/ubbz/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=163167&page=1

Not just us with the problem. Great pads until they fall to bits and IMO, once bitten, twice shy.

Must be many more failings but I only follow the megane and lotus sites.

Streetfighter
05-01-2012, 22:29:40
http://www.exiges.com/ubbz/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=163167&page=1

Not just us with the problem. Great pads until they fall to bits and IMO, once bitten, twice shy.

Must be many more failings but I only follow the megane and lotus sites.

Ouch. Not a fan of the "not for road use therefore hard luck" response. Not the attitude to win in business is it. Tut, tut.
Time to steer clear?

fredrickr26
05-01-2012, 22:34:39
Ouch. Not a fan of the "not for road use therefore hard luck" response. Not the attitude to win in business is it. Tut, tut.
Time to steer clear?

It is for me. I never thought to send them back so cost me front and rears which failed within a couple of hundred miles of each other. Shame as they where a great all rounder.

Streetfighter
05-01-2012, 22:46:25
It is for me. I never thought to send them back so cost me front and rears which failed within a couple of hundred miles of each other. Shame as they where a great all rounder.

On exige.com there's a bit of positive news that the supplier and in turn the manufacturer paid a refund and showed concern. I wonder if this was ever confirmed as a closed issue?
Same failures seen on vx220 site too.

fredrickr26
05-01-2012, 22:48:39
On exige.com there's a bit of positive news that the supplier and in turn the manufacturer paid a refund and showed concern. I wonder if this was ever confirmed and the cause identified and rectified?
Same issues seen on vx220 site too.

Yeh I saw that but no news of a conclusion.

Bahnstormer
05-01-2012, 23:12:34
So what I said seems fair?

Streetfighter
05-01-2012, 23:17:51
Seems so, I like to fish for a more rounded perspective.

fredrickr26
05-01-2012, 23:19:12
So what I said seems fair?

For me and you I would say it's more than fair. Others can take the gamble if they wish as we can only point out our experiences using cl pads. We both agree they where great pads until the failings.

R26RScott
06-01-2012, 10:03:15
Matt / Kev, - can I ask, what are the specs of your fronts (have you upgraded the rears also?)

btw - I'm doing Bedford Sat 18/2 & Spa 15/4

Streetfighter
06-01-2012, 15:17:22
Matt / Kev, - can I ask, what are the specs of your fronts (have you upgraded the rears also?)

btw - I'm doing Bedford Sat 18/2 & Spa 15/4

Not sure sure I should tell you if you're thinking about selling up already?? (joke)

Is Spa £340?

R26RScott
06-01-2012, 16:00:30
lol....I'm not sure I want to sell tbh......I have been mulling over buying an X-Bow with a mate (that's 2 of us buying the car, not a car that comes with a "mate")

Yes, Spa is £340(ish) - Gold Track

liquidf1
06-01-2012, 17:38:12
I have used the pagid rs5's for over 2 years now, never felt the need to change been so impressed with them. I ran the ds2500s before and wasn't impressed.

Bahnstormer
06-01-2012, 19:54:34
I use PF07's and PF01's on the rear. Im not telling you anymore if you're selling. Xbow's are ****e and cold and miserable.

Dale
06-01-2012, 21:53:42
I have used the pagid rs5's for over 2 years now, never felt the need to change been so impressed with them. I ran the ds2500s before and wasn't impressed.

ds3000 are somert else totally different feel to the 2500's ive started using 2500's on the back with the 3000's up front really happy with them never been able to fault ferodo pads

g10far
07-01-2012, 14:19:31
I have used the pagid rs5's for over 2 years now, never felt the need to change been so impressed with them. I ran the ds2500s before and wasn't impressed.

I like the idea of using pagids, and from what I heard they are mega but pricey. Ive been looking at Rs29's but are very pricey, I too didn't think the DS2500 were that good!

HoopsR26R
07-01-2012, 14:44:02
Ive just noticed this thread - ive actually posted about the CL's in another section on here before reading - I'm obviously quite disappointed to read this now!! I think i will take the advice of Bahnstormer and try the PF pads.
One quick question - what are the best discs to marry these pads with?? And any other suggestions/advice on brake upgrades?? i.e.. what is best fluid to put in and are braided hoses essential to do as well??

Bahnstormer
07-01-2012, 14:46:13
PF Discs.

HoopsR26R
07-01-2012, 14:54:31
Thanks Bahn. Apologies if ive duplicated in my own post! Will give this a try as and when required.

Out of interest - has anyone with an R26R tried an AP set up? AP callipers etc? Are they available for the R26R?

conley
07-01-2012, 17:30:46
Thanks Bahn. Apologies if ive duplicated in my own post! Will give this a try as and when required.

Out of interest - has anyone with an R26R tried an AP set up? AP callipers etc? Are they available for the R26R?

For the Meg the PF discs are a better choice.

AP calipers? Not required. The OEM 4 pots do a good job and if you went for a caliper torque upgrade as well as the 330mm discs you would end up with a very large front braking bias shift. Not good. You do need to keep and eye on the F/R braking balance.

The rear discs have integral bearings and are not easily upgraded. Same with the rear caliper + integral handbrake.

Streetfighter
07-01-2012, 17:47:18
For the Meg the PF discs are a better choice.



Why's that please?

Bahnstormer
07-01-2012, 18:00:08
Because AP discs are cheese.

Streetfighter
07-01-2012, 18:23:57
Because AP discs are cheese.

Good. Have you ever run any on a Megane?

Bahnstormer
07-01-2012, 18:25:08
Nope I learnt my lesson on a previous car and moved to PF then too (first time at the time).

Streetfighter
07-01-2012, 18:29:52
Nope I learnt my lesson on a previous car and moved to PF then too (first time at the time).

OK, which pads did you use on the previous car with the cheesey discs?

conley
07-01-2012, 19:02:10
Why's that please?

As per Bahns answer. The APs are OK but you get more life out of the PFs for similar usage/same pad.

steven878
07-01-2012, 20:16:06
[QUOTE=conley;624521]For the Meg the PF discs are a better choice

I thought the pf discs only come in 330mm and this would upset the braking balance of the car?

conley
07-01-2012, 20:24:31
[QUOTE=conley;624521]For the Meg the PF discs are a better choice

I thought the pf discs only come in 330mm and this would upset the braking balance of the car?

Correct, but the original question was based on a comparison between PF and AP discs.

HoopsR26R
07-01-2012, 22:54:46
So, I'm gauging then that the most popular choice would be PF discs and pads all round?? Then braided lines and racing fluid and you're set, yes?

conley
08-01-2012, 15:40:28
So, I'm gauging then that the most popular choice would be PF discs and pads all round?? Then braided lines and racing fluid and you're set, yes?

There is no popular choice. If you detail what you are looking to use the R26R for, how you drive and what you expect circuit wise, then there will be some good advice and experience floating about.

HoopsR26R
08-01-2012, 17:06:01
Well, now that i officially own my own R26.R (Number 014) its worth mentioning that it is purely for track days and maybe the odd blast out on a sunny Sunday. The CL pads and KTR discs seemed pretty impressive to me on the drive home but my first track day will be all telling i guess. Thanks for the help and advice Conley and Bahn.